2021-05-14 ULMS Steering Committee Meeting Agenda

Date

May 14, 2021

Time

1-2:30

Zoom

https://csueb.zoom.us/j/531982611

Participants

@John Wenzler @ANGEL PICHARDO (Unlicensed) @Mark Braden (Unlicensed) @brandon dudley (Unlicensed) @Gabriel Gardner (Unlicensed) @Jamie Lamberti (Unlicensed) @Kate Holvoet (Unlicensed) @Mike DeMars (Unlicensed) @Nerissa Lindsey @Natalya Magazino (Unlicensed) @Adriana Popescu @Laura Krier

Discussion topics

Time

Item

Presenter

Notes

Time

Item

Presenter

Notes

1:00-1:05

Welcome

@John Wenzler

 

1:05-1:15

COLD Report

@John Wenzler

COLD will be discussing the Rapido proposal and the Discovery Committee’s recommendation on Primo VE at their June meeting. We expect that a final decision on both products will be made at or immediately after this meeting and will be communicated to all of the libraries.

1:15-1:30

Committee Recruitment

@brandon dudley (Unlicensed)

 

Call for nominations has been sent out. Steering Committee members can encourage people to talk to their deans about being nominated. Chairs are encouraged to get together with Vice Chairs to hand-off committee business and prepare an year-end summary of activities. June meeting is a joint meeting that includes outgoing and incoming Chairs.

1:30-1:45

Ex Libris Customer Service Top Issues

@brandon dudley (Unlicensed)

While it may be time consuming, there is value in participating in the meetings with Ex Libris and Brandon would like input from those who already participated in these meetings. RM and Fulfillment are the only groups left to submit top issues and meet with Ex Libris.

1:45-1:55

Proposed Policy : Excluded MARC Fields

@Mark Braden (Unlicensed)

 

1:45-2:30

Functional Committee Reports

All

Resource Sharing

  • Worked with the FFC to draft revised quarantine guidelines and recommendation for CSU+ due dates. 

  • Met with ExLibris about our Alma issues. An enhancement was recently accepted that would resolve our #1 issue since the inception of CSU+ which is the inability of ILLiad due dates to transfer over into Alma via the NCIP integration. ExLibris hopes the enhancement will be in place by early next year. ExLibris also proposed a solution to our longstanding CalState Walk-in issue, whereby Cal State Walk-in users were unable to submit CSU+ requests. Additionally, a solution was proposed for our “convert to resource sharing” issue. The RSFC will test and confirm that both solutions are effective with the goal of having both solutions in place by fall semester. 

  • Had first meeting with Unity Courier. Discussed options for adding additional UC campuses to the CSUs courier route. Will meet with Unity courier monthly to discuss issues and ensure things are going smoothly.

Resource Management

  • Members of the Resource Management Committee who are part of the Norm Rules Task Force have participated in the Norm Rules discussions and efforts as configuration and testing of Primo VE has continued.

  • 2021 Customer Service Survey: Resource Management folk are building statements and use case information for RM’s participation in the conversations with Ex Libris.

  • Prepared a Draft Policy on MARC Fields Excluded from use by CSU Libraries. The Primo VE effort brought out the need to identify and isolate MARC fields that are unused in NZ and IZs, to ensure that future tests/configuration can occur safely. This is intended as a dynamic document, with fields removed as they are released for specific uses.

  • Preparing for the end of the fiscal year:

    • approaching changes in Chair/Vice-Chair

    • articulating a statement of Task Force activities during 2020-2021

Fulfillment

  • Met with the RSFC to develop recommendations for CSU+ due dates and Quarantine guidelines.

  • Began planning a joint Summer Re-opening Open Forum with the RSFC.

  • Started the committee transition.

ERM

  • Review CZ updates Button in Alma


Alma Collection with portfolios>Click on the three-dot menu (…)>Edit Service>upper right-hand corner

Issue #1 - Changes to records and CDI are taking too long to show up in OneSearch

  • Metadata Corrections
    At the Ex Libris level, CDI re-indexes twice a week.
    When you submit a trouble ticket for a single record metadata correction, it will take 3-7 days AFTER Ex Libris notifies you that the record has been updated for the change to be reflected in Primo.

  • CDI rights processing (changes to CDI settings in the NZ or the IZ)

  • Linking Syntax issue

    • Once Ex Libris fixes the collection level linking syntax (link resolver type collections) and updates the linking parser - the parser is maintained at the global level and is a part of the global alma release - so it is updated in the weekly CBK update on Sundays.

  • CDI Inheritance Activation Workflows

    • Inheriting from the Network Zone CDI - no one should have inherited from Primo Central.

    • CDI inheritance is all or nothing - but institutions can deviate by editing the NZ settings (as far as I can tell).
      *****If you don't inherit CDI settings from the NZ, but you link to the NZ collection, what happens????? Ex Libris is checking on this
      If you activate a full-text collection in the NZ, it's active for all members unless otherwise noted.

    • CDI inheritance is only for people who were inheriting from Primo Central.

    • You can override inheritance settings in the NZ or activate the collection in the IZ to have different settings.

    • Inheritance is relevant for activation for search, for subscribe to only some titles, and do not show even if active in Alma.

    • If an institution inherits CDI activation for a collection from the NZ, but then activates the same collection in the IZ, it will override the NZ settings. If you want Network coordination, link to the collection, don't activate it locally.

Issue #2 Metadata errors CDI and CZ -want to be able to fix metadata errors ourselves

  • Fixing Alma Community Zone Records

    • Single record Alma metadata edits are possible in the CZ Community Zone through the "contribution process" Community Zone Contribution Guidelines
      no local fields allowed

    • Once it is changed in the CZ, it will update in Alma when the CZ pipe next updates (dependant on local scheduling) and in local Primo when it next updates (which should be twice a day?). Expect the update within a day.

  • CDI Metadata updates

    • no individual ability to update CDI metadata records

  • Ex Libris is investigating methods for title checks and linking improvements which may assit in resolving the above - getting member editing rights is more complicated legally due to vendor data licensing agreements.

Issue 3 - Community Zone Updates and records are causing extra work for ERM and Cataloging Staff

  • It takes 6-10 days to make a correction for e-collections and have it be released in the next weekly update. So in our example, they broke Safari in one weekly release and the fix would be released in 6-10 days. I believe it was a little longer than 10 days for Safari but normally if something breaks, that is how long it takes to fix it.

  • No traction on the issue that they break things and we have to do extra work to deal with the fallout

Discovery

The Discovery Functional Committee would like to thank each and every Primo admin for participating in the Go VE Self-Switch process and evaluation!

Testing concluded at the end of April and the cmte. has analyzed all the quantitative data as well as individual comments submitted via the testing forms and via email. The ULMS Steering Committee has tasked the DFC with making recommendation about whether to adopt VE and the potential timing of that move. Discovery’s recommendation will be sent to the Steering Committee on May 21st, and later to COLD for the final decision by their June 17th meeting. 

Assessment & Analytics

None this month.

Acquisitions

  • we discussed our upcoming meeting with Ex Libris on our Top Three Issues from the Satisfaction Survey 

  • We also had a round robin discussion about how different libraries handle standing orders in ALMA, and how to manage those encumbrances.

Action items

Decisions